Prepared forRachel Dombrowski, Toebe Construction LLC
Prepared byJim Worth, Formcode
Five of the 13 calls Toebe bid that day. Each one has the brief estimating would get before the letting, plus the answer key from the posted bid tabs. Read the brief, guess the result, then open the answer.
What this gets Toebe
Win more MDOT bids with the same estimating team.
On every letting, estimating gets a one-page brief on each call before bids go in, and a check on the draft bid against Toebe's own pricing history before it's submitted. From January 2025 to February 2026 Toebe won 6 of the 54 MDOT calls it bid. On March 6, Toebe lost Morris Road by $30,284 in a seven-bidder field, and the check flags foundation excavation priced at $55 against Toebe's typical $42. At Toebe's own typical price, that one line closes $14,521 of the gap. Nothing gets submitted until someone has decided those lines on purpose.
Built only from public MDOT files: the notice of advertisement, the preliminary bid list, the amendment listing, and item-level bid tabs for 19 lettings (Jan 10, 2025 to Feb 6, 2026). "Toebe typical" is the median of Toebe's own unit prices for the same item on those lettings. The real version would also read the full proposal, special provisions and plans from Toebe's e-Proposal account, which aren't public. The tool reads and drafts. Estimators price.
Letting day at a glance
13
calls bid on Mar 6
2
won
$5.42M
in low bids
1
lost by under 3%
Call
Job
Toebe bid
Result
002
Forest Ave over M-10, Detroit
$662,641
3rd of 4, +15.1%
007
Valley Rd roundabout at Occidental Hwy, Lenawee Co
$678,146
Won by $61,731
010
Morris Rd over S Branch Flint River, Lapeer Co
$1,869,000
4th of 7, +1.6%
018
Valley Ave reconstruction, Grand Rapids
$1,612,642
4th of 4, +24.6%
022
US-127BR culvert, St. Johns
$2,677,026
4th of 5, +17.3%
028
Two Kalamazoo River bridges, Calhoun Co
$4,485,000
3rd of 4, +15.5%
034
Packard St resurfacing and water main, Ann Arbor
$4,738,209
Won by $410,020
035
E Walton Blvd concrete repair, Pontiac
$2,661,119
6th of 7, +42.1%
037
Emburke Blvd and Edgeorge St over Clinton River
$3,123,500
2nd of 4, +9.3%
040
Two Barry County bridge replacements
$2,693,860
6th of 7, +28.7%
042
Pontiac Trail reconstruction and signals, South Lyon
$12,978,978
4th of 5, +12.6%
043
Perry Road Trail, Genesee Co
$2,586,479
4th of 5, +17.7%
049
Island Lake Rd roundabout at Dexter-Chelsea Rd
$3,313,811
2nd of 3, +4.2%
Percent is Toebe's bid over the low bid. "Won by" is the gap to the second bidder. The briefs below cover calls 007, 010, 034, 035 and 049.
What the history already shows
Toebe on MDOT lettings, Jan 2025 to Feb 2026
54 calls bid across 16 lettings, 6 won (11%).
Head-to-head, Toebe's bid was lower than: Major Contracting in 8 of 10 shared calls, Fonson 7 of 11, Z Contractors 10 of 25, C.A. Hull 8 of 20, Anlaan 6 of 16, and only 4 of 23 against Dan's Excavating.
Minor Traffic Devices: Toebe's median is $173,700 across 53 bids. The median low-bidder price for that line across all calls on the same 19 lettings is $25,298, about 7 times lower.
Asphalt: Toebe's typical HMA 5EML is $130.00/ton (21 bids) against a low-bidder median of $103.91 (142). HMA 4EML is $120.00 (18 bids) against $94.32 (127). Haul distance, plant pricing or deliberate front-loading could explain any of these. That's the estimator's call. The tool just puts it in front of you.
The briefs
Five calls, before and after.
Each brief below is what estimating would have had before the March 6 letting. Read it, decide how you'd bid it, then open the result.
1Call 007: Valley Rd roundabout at Occidental Hwy
HSIP 46000-222011 · Lenawee County · Local Agency
Scope
0.21 mi roundabout: HMA reconstruction, concrete curb and gutter, signing, tree removals, drainage and pavement markings.
Key facts
CompletionOct 25, 2026
Plansabout 32 pages
DBE / SBP0% / 3%
Prequal747 Cb or Ea
Items67
Amendmentsnone listed
Who's on the bid list (Toebe lower in shared calls)
Erie Construction: 3 of 3
Michigan Paving and Materials: 0 of 2
Rieth-Riley: 0 of 1
Slusarski Excavating & Paving: no shared calls since Jan 2025
Cost drivers with Toebe history
Item
Qty
Toebe typical
HMA, 5EML
361 ton
$130.00 (21 bids)
Excavation, Earth
1,610 cyd
$25.00 (36)
HMA, 4EML
330 ton
$120.00 (18)
Curb and Gutter, Conc, Det B2
1,161 ft
$32.50 (9)
Conc Pavt, Misc, Nonreinf, 6 inch
583 syd
$60.00 (3)
HMA, 3C
660 ton
1 Toebe bid; market $121.00 (3)
Price from scratch
Only 3 of 67 items: 10-inch nonreinforced concrete pavement, temporary roadway, and 12-inch Class F culvert.
Watch
Subclasses Cb, Ea and J. Confirm Toebe's prequal or name the subs before award.
Two asphalt producers on the preliminary list. Toebe's HMA history runs above the low-bidder median, so the mix quote matters.
One-season roundabout with an Oct 25 finish. Check the proposal for staging and detour requirements.
Show the result
Engineer's estimate$747,942
Toebe$678,146, low of 3
Next bidSlusarski $739,876
Where the gap came from (Toebe vs Slusarski)
HMA base crushing and shaping: $1.50 vs $14.25/syd (2,388 syd)
HMA, 3C: $95 vs $118/ton
Embankment, CIP: $9 vs $23/cyd
Minor Traffic Devices: $57,000 vs $25,000 (offsetting)
Bid check against Toebe's own history
On a win the check runs the other way. Embankment went in at $9/cyd against Toebe's typical $24.11 (31 bids). At Toebe's typical price that line alone is $14,642 higher, which is money the bid didn't need to give up if the low price wasn't intentional.
Takeaway: A clean win, 9.3% under the engineer's estimate, with almost nothing priced from scratch. On a job like this the tool's value is after the letting: $61,731 was left on the table to the next bid, and it shows which lines it came from.
2Call 010: Morris Rd over South Branch Flint River
BFPO 44000-220723 · Lapeer County · Local Agency
Scope
Bridge reconstruction: 21-inch prestressed spread box beams, CIP abutments, steel H-piles, cofferdams, drainage, guardrail, approach work and markings.
Key facts
CompletionMay 28, 2027
Plansabout 68 pages
DBE / SBP0% / 3%
Prequal1637 Fa
Items84
Amendmentsnone listed
Who's on the bid list (Toebe lower in shared calls)
Dan's Excavating: 4 of 23
Z Contractors: 10 of 25
C.A. Hull: 8 of 20
Anlaan: 6 of 16
Davis: 2 of 8
M-K Construction: 3 of 5
Miller Bridge: 2 of 5
Grand River: 1 of 5
Trojan Development: 1 of 1
Cost drivers with Toebe history
Item
Qty
Toebe typical
Pile, Steel, Furn and Driven, 12 inch
4,540 ft
$64.78 (2 bids)
Cofferdams
LSUM
$175,000 (1)
Structures, Rem
LSUM
$172,500 (2)
Substructure Conc
183 cyd
$865.00 (6)
Superstructure Conc, Night Casting
LSUM
$140,000 (3)
Prest Conc Box Beam, Furn, 21 inch
270 ft
$473.00 (2)
Price from scratch
Just 1 of 84 items (a $5,000 crack-sealing lump sum). Everything else has been priced before by Toebe or by the low bidders. Expect a tight spread.
Watch
Ten firms on the preliminary list, and the three who usually beat Toebe are all on it.
River work with cofferdams and 4,540 ft of H-pile. Toebe has only 2 prior pile bids, so get the pile and driving quotes early.
Box beam supplier quote and the 3% SBP goal.
Show the result
Engineer's estimate$1,637,035
Low bidZ Contractors $1,838,716
Toebe$1,869,000, 4th of 7
Bid check against Toebe's own history
Excavation, Fdn went in at $55/cyd on 1,117 cyd. Toebe's typical is $42 (26 bids), and Z Contractors carried $27. At Toebe's typical price that line is $14,521 lower, which closes about half of the $30,284 gap on its own.
Other big differences (Toebe vs Z, mostly offsetting)
Minor Traffic Devices: $140,000 vs $5,000
Cofferdams: $200,000 vs $275,000
Steel pile splices: $0.01 vs $500 each (72)
Structures, Rem: $100,000 vs $134,500
Takeaway: Lost by 1.6% in a seven-bidder field. Minor Traffic Devices alone was $135,000 above Z, more than four times the whole gap, though it went in under Toebe's own typical for that line. Intentional moves stay. Accidental ones get caught.
3Call 034: Packard St, Main to State, Ann Arbor
STU 81000-214689 · Washtenaw County · Local Agency
Scope
0.60 mi of HMA milling and resurfacing, curb, gutter, sidewalk and ramps, storm sewer repairs, water main replacement, signing and markings.
Key facts
CompletionJun 1, 2027
Plansabout 89 pages
DBE / SBP0% / 6%
Prequal5261 K, or Cb and Ea joint
Items186
Amendments1 and 2
Who's on the bid list (Toebe lower in shared calls)
Major Contracting: 8 of 10
Fonson: 7 of 11
Cost drivers with Toebe history
Item
Qty
Toebe typical
Machine Grading, Modified
31 sta
$9,792.50 (4 bids)
Pavt, Rem, Modified
13,286 syd
$15.50 (12)
Aggregate Base, 8 inch, 21AA, Modified
13,422 syd
$14.00 (2)
HMA, 3EML, Modified
2,176 ton
1 Toebe bid at $96.35
HMA, 5EML, Modified
1,057 ton
1 Toebe bid at $96.50
HMA, 4EML, Modified
988 ton
1 Toebe bid at $87.50
Price from scratch
96 of 186 items, including 3,324 ft of 12-inch ductile iron water main, 17 gate valves in wells, temporary water main line stops, 2,989 syd of trolley track removal, and green polymer bike lane markings.
Watch
Amendments 1 and 2 are posted. Make sure both are in the bid.
The water main is the job. Pipe, valve and utility sub quotes decide it.
Trolley track removal is unusual. Check the proposal for disposal and any historic-material requirements.
6% SBP goal, plus Cb, Ea and K subclasses.
Show the result
Engineer's estimate$5,261,419
Toebe$4,738,209, low of 3
Next bidMajor $5,148,229
Where the gap came from (Toebe vs Major)
12-inch DIP water main: $195 vs $284/ft ($648,180 vs $944,016)
Trolley track removal: $18 vs $40/syd
12-inch gate valves: $11,000 vs $14,600 each
Minor Traffic Devices: $221,000 vs $100,000 (offsetting)
Water service tap and lead: $175 vs $100/ft (offsetting)
Takeaway: Won by $410,020 (8%), and the water main is where it was won: the pipe line alone was $295,836 under Major. The "price from scratch" lines were 55% of the engineer's estimate, which is exactly where the brief pointed. The debrief question is how much of that pipe price was left on the table.
4Call 035: E Walton Blvd, Baldwin to Joslyn, Pontiac
STU 63000-215086 · Oakland County · Local Agency
Scope
1.00 mi of concrete pavement repair, drainage, curb, gutter, ramps, signing and markings.
Key facts
CompletionOct 31, 2026
Plansabout 51 pages
DBE / SBP0% / 6%
Prequal2733 Ba, or B and Ea joint
Items73
Amendmentsnone listed
Who's on the bid list (Toebe lower in shared calls)
Major Contracting: 8 of 10
C & D Hughes: 2 of 3
Angelo Iafrate: 1 of 5
Florence Cement: 1 of 3
Cipparrone: 0 of 1
Great Lakes Contracting Solutions: no shared calls since Jan 2025
Cost drivers with Toebe history
Item
Qty
Toebe typical
Pavt Repr, Nonreinf Conc, 11 inch
4,864 syd
no Toebe history; market $143.55 (3)
Pavt Repr, Rem
4,864 syd
$29.00 (5)
Joint, Contraction, Crg
6,569 ft
$19.25 (12)
Pavt, Rem
5,885 syd
$17.91 (28)
Lane Tie, Epoxy Anchored
10,527 ea
$10.00 (17)
Joint, Contraction, Cp
5,681 ft
$12.00 (14)
Price from scratch
6 of 73 items, led by 5,885 syd of 11-inch nonreinforced concrete pavement (half a million dollars at the engineer's price), plus an 8-inch sewer and a Grand Trunk Western crossing protection line.
Watch
Concrete paving job with two bidders who usually beat Toebe. Worth a bid/no-bid talk.
Short window: Oct 31, 2026 completion.
Railroad crossing line is in the items. Check the proposal for Grand Trunk Western requirements.
6% SBP and B, Ba, Ea subclasses.
Show the result
Engineer's estimate$2,733,615
Low bidCipparrone $1,872,932
Toebe$2,661,119, 6th of 7
Bid check against Toebe's own history
Five lines worth $1.58M, 59% of Toebe's total, went in at exactly the engineer's unit price. Two lines also sit well off Toebe's own history:
Joint, Contraction, Cp: $25.00 vs typical $12.00 (14 bids).
At Toebe's typical prices, those two lines are $174,428 lower.
Other big differences (Toebe vs Cipparrone)
Mobilization: $248,000 (the max) vs $90,400
Minor Traffic Devices: $204,200 vs $93,700
11-inch concrete pavement: $85.00 vs $67.85/syd
Pavt Repr, Rem: $35.00 vs $17.60/syd
Takeaway: Not close: $788,187 over (42%). If this was priced to pass, fine. If it was a real target, the check would have flagged the engineer's-price lines first, before the bid went in.
5Call 049: Island Lake Rd roundabout at Dexter-Chelsea Rd
CPMG 81000-214986 · Washtenaw County · Local Agency
Scope
0.43 mi intersection rebuild: roundabout with widening for turn lanes, traffic signal modernizations and sidewalk ramp upgrades.
Key facts
CompletionMay 28, 2027
Plansabout 94 pages
DBE / SBP0% / 3%
Prequal3342 Ea
Items241
Amendmentsnone listed
Who's on the bid list (Toebe lower in shared calls)
Dan's Excavating: 4 of 23
Fonson: 7 of 11
Cost drivers with Toebe history
Item
Qty
Toebe typical
HMA, 4EML
1,480 ton
$120.00 (18 bids)
Aggregate Base, 10 inch, Modified
8,003 syd
$21.45 (2)
Excavation, Earth, Modified
4,513 cyd
no Toebe history; market $30.00 (2)
Embankment, CIP, Modified
2,523 cyd
$44.17 (4)
HMA, 5EML
645 ton
$130.00 (21)
Sewer, Cl IV, 15 inch, Tr Det B
469 ft
$143.00 (2)
Price from scratch
27 of 241 items, mostly signal work: over-height vehicle detection, five controller and cabinet assemblies, solar rapid flashing beacons, and system integration support.
Watch
Cb and L subclasses. The signal sub's quote covers most of the unpriced lines.
241 items on 94 plan pages for a three-bidder field. Small field, big takeoff.
Dan's Excavating is on the preliminary list, and usually comes in under Toebe.
Show the result
Engineer's estimate$3,342,063
Low bidFonson $3,179,981
Toebe$3,313,811, 2nd of 3
Bid check against Toebe's own history
Aggregate base went in at $30/syd, above both the engineer ($25) and Toebe's own two prior bids ($21.45). Fonson carried $18. Thin history, so read it as a hint, but at $21.45 the line is $68,426 lower, about half the $133,830 gap.
Other big differences (Toebe vs Fonson)
Excavation, Earth, Modified: $25 vs $32/cyd (offsetting)
Minor Traffic Devices: $122,000 vs $99,620
Temporary pedestrian path: $41 vs $12/ft
Shoulder, Cl II, 6 inch: $55.00 vs $15.27/syd
Takeaway: Lost by 4.2% in a three-bidder field, and the aggregate base line alone was $96,036 of the $133,830 gap against Fonson. A flag on the draft bid would have put that line in front of the estimator before submission.
How it runs on your next letting
When the ads post. A brief on every call that fits Toebe's work: who's likely bidding and how Toebe has done against them, the lines that need quotes, and what to watch. Bid/no-bid takes minutes instead of an afternoon.
The day before. The preliminary bid list posts, and each brief updates with who actually picked up plans.
While pricing. The brief names the lines that decide the job, so supplier and sub quote requests go out early.
Before submitting. The draft bid is checked against Toebe's own history. Every line priced well off it, or sitting exactly at the engineer's price, gets a flag and a reason field. The estimator keeps it or changes it. The tool never touches a price.
When the tabs post. A same-day debrief: where each loss came from, what was left on the table on each win, and updated head-to-head numbers for the next letting.
With Toebe's e-Proposal login and PreConSuite quotes connected, the brief also reads the special provisions (working days, liquidated damages, staging), and the check compares against what Toebe actually pays subs and suppliers. It all stays in Toebe's own account.
Next step
Run it live on Call 005 for the December 4 letting, at no cost.The brief for 005 is already built. Send the AASHTOWare bid file a few days before the letting and you get the check before you submit, then judge it on a real letting.
Private demo built from public MDOT bid letting files; not affiliated with MDOT. Sources: MDOT Bid Letting; letting of March 6, 2026 (notice of advertisement, preliminary bid list, amendment listing, as-submitted results, and the item tabs for calls 007, 010, 034, 035 and 049); item bid tabs for 19 lettings from Jan 10, 2025 to Feb 6, 2026. Items are matched by MDOT description and unit. "Typical" is a median, and counts are Toebe bids on that item. Market figures are the median low-bidder price across the same lettings.
formcodeStrategic Digital Growth Partner since 2000