formcode›
November 2026
Letting Brief · before the bids go in

Toebe Construction

MDOT letting of December 4, 2026 · Call 005

Prepared forRachel Dombrowski, Toebe Construction LLC
Prepared byJim Worth, Formcode

US-127 through Lansing and East Lansing, built November 18 from the public files and Toebe's own bid history. This is the brief estimating gets before bid day. The results get added the day MDOT posts the tabs. Want the format on a finished letting first? Here's the March 6 test.

What this gets Toebe

A deliberate number on every line of a $125M bid.

Call 005 has 785 pay items, and 246 of them have no price history from Toebe or anyone else. Toebe has bid 8 MDOT jobs over $20M in the past year and finished second on four of them. On the two closest, the Minor Traffic Devices line alone was bigger than the whole gap. The brief points estimating at the lines that decide this job, and the check makes sure each one was decided on purpose before the bid goes in.

Built only from public MDOT files: the notice of advertisement, the schedule of pay items, the amendment listing and the preliminary bid list, plus item-level bid tabs for 21 lettings (Oct 3, 2025 to Nov 6, 2026). "Toebe typical" is the median of Toebe's own unit prices for the same item on those lettings. "Low-bidder median" is the median winning price for that item on the same lettings. The proposal, special provisions and plans sit behind e-Proposal, so anything from those is marked "check the proposal." The tool reads and drafts. Estimators price.

The job at a glance

~$125M
prequal 124,761 Fa, which tracks the engineer's estimate in thousands
785
pay items, two project numbers
538
items Toebe has priced before
246
items with no price history at all

Toebe on big MDOT jobs

LettingCallLow bidderResult
Oct 3, 2025019Dan's Excavating3rd of 4, +12.0%
Dec 19, 2025702Ajax Paving2nd of 4, +6.5%
Jan 9, 2026007Michigan Paving and Materials5th of 6, +7.2%
Jun 5, 2026001M & M Excavating / C.A. Hull4th of 4, +25.1%
Jul 24, 2026701C.A. Hull2nd of 3, +23.3%
Jul 24, 2026703Milbocker and Sons4th of 4, +15.2%
Sep 4, 2026013Dan's Excavating2nd of 3, +13.4%
Oct 2, 2026007Dan's Excavating2nd of 3, +3.2%

Calls over $20M that Toebe bid from Oct 2025 to Nov 2026. Percent is Toebe's bid over the low bid. One Nov 21, 2025 call with an $830M estimate is left out because it isn't comparable.

What the history already shows

Toebe on MDOT lettings, Oct 2025 to Nov 2026
  • 71 calls bid across 18 lettings, 13 won (18%). None of the 8 big jobs above were wins, and Toebe came in second on four.
  • Dan's Excavating bid four of the big jobs and finished ahead of Toebe every time.
  • Minor Traffic Devices on the two closest big losses: on Dec 19, 2025 Call 702 (US-23, concrete and 5 bridges), Toebe carried $9,005,083 against Ajax's $4,481,357 and lost by $3,667,779. On Oct 2, 2026 Call 007 (Pontiac, concrete reconstruction), Toebe carried $4,400,000 against Dan's $1,787,163 and lost by $1,494,212. If Toebe carries its traffic control in that line on purpose, it stays. That's the estimator's call. The tool just puts it in front of you.
The brief

Call 005, before the bids go in.

Everything below comes from the public files posted through November 18. It updates when the preliminary bid list is reposted and again when the tabs post.

1Call 005: US-127, Red Cedar to south of Lake Lansing Rd

NH 33171-132605 · Ingham County · MDOT
Scope

2.21 mi of concrete roadway reconstruction with water main, drainage, guardrail, signals, signing and markings, plus reconstruction and rehabilitation of several structures on US-127 through Lansing and East Lansing.

Key facts
CompletionSep 30, 2029
Plansabout 1,107 pages
DBE / SBP0% / 5%
Prequal124761 Fa, plus B and Ea subclasses
Items785
Amendments1 posted (as of Nov 18)
Mobilization cap$11,342,000
Warrantiestwo 5-yr pavement, 2-yr surface coating, 2-yr bridge coating, 5-yr epoxy
Also in the itemsDispute Review Board, CPM schedule, $597,200 concrete quality initiative
Who's on the bid list

MDOT's preliminary list for Call 005 showed no names as of November 17. It's usually reposted the day before the letting, and the head-to-head records go in once names appear.

Cost drivers with Toebe history
ItemQtyToebe typicalLow-bidder median
Structural Steel, Plate, Furn and Fab2,837,760 lb$3.25 (7 bids)$3.03 (13)
Excavation, Earth172,185 cyd$25.00 (50)$25.05 (319)
Shld, Nonreinf Conc, High Performance47,185 syd$75.00 (5)$75.00 (7)
Substructure Conc, High Performance3,727 cyd$815.50 (14)$987.50 (24)
Pavt, Rem123,177 syd$15.00 (41)$18.25 (254)
Subbase, CIP44,353 cyd$40.00 (38)$30.91 (206)
Price from scratch

246 of 785 items have no history from Toebe or the low bidders. 128 of them are lump sums tied to specific structures: removals and demolition plans, superstructure form, finish and cure, coatings, cofferdams, causeways and structure surveys. The biggest unit-price items with no history are 62,585 syd of 9 1/2 inch nonreinforced high-performance concrete pavement (the mainline), 69,744 cyd of Embankment, CIP, Spec, 715,980 lb of low-carbon chromium reinforcement, 4,967 ft of 54 inch and 1,376 ft of 84 inch drilled shaft, and 3,730 cyd of expanded polystyrene lightweight fill. These get priced off quotes and takeoff, not history.

Watch
  • Amendment 1 is posted. Numeric amendments have to be integrated into the electronic bid before submission.
  • The steel quote: 2.84M lb of plate girder plus complex steel erection lump sums on B01 and B02. The fabricator and erector numbers likely decide the bridge side.
  • Water work: cofferdams, temporary causeways, drilled shafts and an obstruction removal allowance on B01 and B02. Check the proposal for in-water work windows and causeway requirements.
  • Utilities: asbestos survey items for a Consumers Energy gas main and an unknown-owner duct bank, plus a $73,000 asbestos removal allowance. Check the proposal for coordination requirements.
  • 5% SBP and B and Ea subclasses. Name prequalified subs before award if Toebe isn't prequalified in them.
  • A schedule running to Sep 2029, with a Dispute Review Board, a CPM schedule and four warranties to carry.
Show the lines to decide on purpose
Where Toebe's typical sits furthest from the low bidders, at 005's quantities
  • Steel plate furnish and fab: $3.25 vs $3.03/lb (+$624,307)
  • Excavation, Fdn: $40.00 vs $25.95/cyd on 37,885 cyd (+$532,474)
  • Steel plate erect: $0.57 vs $0.40/lb (+$482,419)
  • Subbase, CIP: $40.00 vs $30.91/cyd (+$403,169)
  • Substructure conc, high performance: $815.50 vs $987.50/cyd (Toebe lower by $641,044)
  • Pavt, Rem: $15.00 vs $18.25/syd (Toebe lower by $400,325)
  • Epoxy-coated reinforcement: $1.90 vs $2.40/lb on 676,215 lb (Toebe lower by $338,108)
Minor Traffic Devices

On Toebe's two closest big losses, the gap on this one lump sum was bigger than the gap on the whole bid. For 005, it's worth a deliberate number before December 4.

Takeaway: Haul, plant, crews or deliberate pricing can explain any of these. The check puts each one in front of the estimator with a reason field before the bid goes in. Intentional moves stay. Accidental ones get caught.

How it runs from here

  1. Now. This brief, built from the ads, the pay items and Toebe's history.
  2. The day before. The preliminary bid list is reposted, and the brief updates with who actually picked up plans and how Toebe has done against each of them.
  3. While pricing. The brief names the lines that decide the job, so steel, shaft, pavement and structure quote requests go out early.
  4. Before submitting. The draft bid is checked against Toebe's own history. Every line priced well off it, or sitting exactly at the engineer's price, gets a flag and a reason field. The estimator keeps it or changes it. The tool never touches a price.
  5. When the tabs post. A same-day debrief on 005: where it was won or lost, line by line.

With Toebe's e-Proposal login and PreConSuite quotes connected, the brief also reads the special provisions (working days, liquidated damages, staging), and the check compares against what Toebe actually pays subs and suppliers. It all stays in Toebe's own account.

Private brief built from public MDOT bid letting files; not affiliated with MDOT. Sources: MDOT Bid Letting; letting of December 4, 2026 (notice of advertisement, schedule of pay items, preliminary bid list of Nov 17, amendment listing of Nov 18); item bid tabs for 21 lettings from Oct 3, 2025 to Nov 6, 2026; the official tabulations for Dec 19, 2025 Call 702 and Oct 2, 2026 Call 007. Items are matched by MDOT description and unit. "Typical" is a median, and counts are bids on that item. The ~$125M figure is read from the prequal amount, not a published estimate.
formcode  Strategic Digital Growth Partner since 2000
November 2026